
How Can Membership Sites Create Recurring Income?
An Interview With Neil Stafford
Building an online business doesn't always mean creating a new product every time you want to make another sale. Sometimes, the opportunity lies in finding a group of people who need ongoing information and giving them a reason to keep coming back.
Membership sites offer one way to do that. Instead of relying entirely on individual purchases, customers pay for continued access to information, training or resources that help them achieve a particular goal.
But what makes someone join a membership site in the first place? And perhaps more importantly, what makes them stay?
In this archive interview, online marketer Neil Stafford shares his experiences of building internet businesses, finding opportunities in unexpected markets and developing membership sites around subjects that might never occur to most people.
His story includes everything from selling commissioned oil paintings online in the early days of the internet to building a membership business about keeping pet ducks.
Along the way, he offers some interesting perspectives on choosing a niche, creating useful content and avoiding the mistakes that can make an online business unnecessarily complicated.
Listen to the Interview
Neil Stafford: Building Membership Sites and Recurring Income
About Neil Stafford
Neil Stafford's involvement in internet marketing began long before today's website builders, online course platforms and automated payment systems became widely available.
One of his earliest experiences involved helping a friend who produced commissioned oil paintings. At the time, they were advertising through magazines and sending printed information packs to prospective customers.
Neil had been experimenting with building websites and decided to put the information online. The process was far from sophisticated by modern standards. Customers could visit the website, print an order form and send their payment through the post.
Nevertheless, the approach worked.
In May 1998, Neil received a cheque for £95 following an order generated through the website. It was his first internet-generated sale, and it helped demonstrate the commercial possibilities of a medium that was still relatively new.
Neil subsequently developed his involvement in online marketing, exploring different business models and eventually building membership sites around specialist interests.
His experiences provide an interesting perspective on how information-based businesses can develop without necessarily following the most obvious routes.
What You'll Discover in This Interview
The conversation explores several aspects of building and running an online business, particularly the opportunities available through membership sites. Neil discusses how his first online sale changed his thinking about internet marketing, why smaller and more specialised markets can be worth investigating, and how membership businesses can be developed around information people genuinely want.
He also explains why you don't necessarily need to be a recognised expert to build a useful information product, provided you're honest about your knowledge and understand what your audience needs.
Another important theme is the balance between providing enough content to justify a subscription and overwhelming members with more information than they can reasonably use.
The interview also touches on a problem that remains familiar to many online business owners: spending too much time thinking about technology rather than concentrating on the customers the business is supposed to serve.
Finding Opportunities in Unexpected Markets
One of the most interesting aspects of Neil's experience is his willingness to investigate markets that other people might overlook. He describes building a membership business aimed at people coaching junior football teams.
Rather than targeting professional coaches or established football clubs, the membership focused on parents and volunteers who had taken responsibility for helping children learn and enjoy the game.
These people faced practical challenges. They needed ideas for training sessions, ways to organise activities and guidance that suited their circumstances.
Neil worked with a friend who had experience coaching junior football. Together, they shared practical information based on what was happening with the team, including the problems they encountered and the approaches they tried.
The attraction wasn't necessarily advanced football knowledge. It was the relevance of the information to the people receiving it.
A parent coaching a local junior team has very different requirements from someone managing a professional football academy. By recognising that distinction, Neil and his colleague were able to focus on a particular audience with identifiable needs.
It's a useful reminder that an online business doesn't always need to compete for the attention of an enormous market. Sometimes, a smaller audience with a specific problem offers a more practical starting point.
The Membership Site About Keeping Pet Ducks
Perhaps the most memorable story in the interview concerns a membership site devoted to keeping pet ducks.
Neil explains that he was speaking at an event about fixed-term membership sites when he invited the audience to suggest a subject for a demonstration project.
Someone suggested keeping pet ducks.
It wasn't an obvious choice for an information business, but Neil decided to investigate the idea rather than dismiss it. His research suggested there was an audience interested in the subject, although he wasn't personally an expert in keeping ducks.
Instead of attempting to become one, he found someone who already had relevant information and negotiated a licence to use the material. He then organised that content into a nine-month membership programme, with lessons released every two weeks.
Members paid a monthly subscription to receive the information.
The project demonstrated how a specialised subject could be turned into a structured information product without requiring Neil to create every lesson from scratch. It also highlighted the importance of having the appropriate rights when using somebody else's material.
For anyone interested in information publishing, this is one of the more valuable parts of the conversation.
The opportunity isn't necessarily limited to subjects you already know everything about. It may also involve recognising an audience's needs and finding a legitimate way to bring useful information to that audience.
Of course, discovering an interesting niche doesn't guarantee commercial success. The audience still needs to see enough value in the offer to justify paying for it.
Why People Join Membership Sites and Why They Stay
Membership sites have an obvious attraction for business owners.
Instead of making a single sale and then needing to find another customer, a membership model creates the possibility of receiving payments from existing customers over an extended period.
However, recurring payments shouldn't be confused with guaranteed recurring income.
Members can cancel their subscriptions, and a membership business needs to provide continuing value if it wants people to remain.
Neil raises two questions that are worth considering before launching any membership programme.
The first is why someone would want to join.
The second is why that person would continue paying month after month.
These questions might sound similar, but they address different parts of the customer relationship.
Someone may join because they're attracted by a particular promise, a useful resource or the opportunity to solve an immediate problem. Whether they remain a member depends on what happens after they've joined.
Are they receiving the information they expected? Can they find what they need? Are they making progress towards the result they wanted?
Those considerations matter just as much as attracting new subscribers. They also influence the way a membership should be structured, from the amount of content provided to the frequency of new lessons.
Does a Membership Site Need Hundreds of Lessons?
Another interesting point Neil makes concerns the amount of information members receive.
When creating an information product, it's tempting to believe that more content automatically means greater value.
A membership containing hundreds of lessons, recordings and downloadable resources might appear impressive when described on a sales page. But that doesn't necessarily mean members will find it easier to use.
Someone who joins because they want help with a specific problem may feel overwhelmed when presented with an enormous collection of material and no obvious starting point.
Instead of making progress, they may spend their time trying to decide what to study first.
Neil discusses the importance of finding a sensible balance. Members need enough useful information to justify their subscription, but they also need a clear way to use it.
A smaller, well-organised programme that helps people achieve a particular outcome can sometimes be more valuable than a large collection of loosely connected resources.
He also discusses the possibility of delivering training live and building a content library from those sessions.
That approach can allow a membership to develop over time rather than requiring every lesson to be completed before the first customer joins. The important point is that members should understand what they're buying and receive the value they've been promised.
Keeping Technology in Perspective
Technology has changed enormously since Neil received that first £95 cheque in 1998.
Today, someone considering a membership business can choose from numerous platforms offering subscription payments, protected content, automated emails and member management.
Those tools can make running a business easier, but the number of choices can also become a distraction.
It's possible to spend weeks researching platforms, comparing features and planning complicated systems without establishing whether anyone actually wants the proposed membership.
Neil's experiences reinforce the importance of concentrating on the business opportunity first. Who is the membership intended to help? What information do those people need? Why would they pay for it, and what would encourage them to continue?
Once those questions have been answered, choosing suitable technology becomes a more practical exercise.
The software still matters, of course. Members need reliable access to the content they've purchased, and the business needs a dependable way to manage payments and subscriptions.
But technology should support a worthwhile offer rather than become the reason for creating one.
What Makes This Interview Worth Listening To?
What I particularly like about Neil's story is that it challenges some of the assumptions people make about starting an information business.
His first online sale didn't involve sophisticated technology.
His junior football membership wasn't aimed at professional coaches.
His pet duck membership wasn't built around a subject in which he personally claimed expertise.
And his comments about membership content suggest that providing more information isn't always the same as providing more value. These examples illustrate a broader principle: successful information products begin with understanding what a particular group of people wants or needs.
The delivery method matters, but it comes afterwards.
Although the interview comes from an earlier period of internet marketing, the underlying lessons about audiences, offers and customer value remain useful.
For anyone exploring membership sites or recurring-revenue products, Neil's experiences provide several ideas worth considering.
Listen to the Full Interview or Download the Transcript
There's considerably more detail in the conversation than we've covered here, particularly around Neil's early experiences, his approach to finding markets and the practical decisions involved in developing membership businesses.
If you're considering creating a membership site, or simply want to explore another way of selling information online, the full interview is worth listening to.
You can listen using the audio player above or download the complete transcript to read at your own pace.
→ Download the Neil Stafford Interview Transcript (PDF)
Explore More on FAQ Marketing Logic
One of the attractions of a membership business is the opportunity to build a more predictable income rather than starting from zero each month. But memberships aren't the only approach worth exploring. If you're interested in creating an online business with repeatable systems and the potential for ongoing revenue, Make Cash Like Clockwork introduces another way to think about building income without constantly chasing the next sale.
→ Discover Make Cash Like Clockwork
If you'd like to explore the wider principles behind choosing a business model, developing offers and building recurring revenue, the following sections provide a useful starting point.
→ Business: Choosing and Building an Online Business
Explore different business models, identify opportunities and learn how to develop an offer people are willing to pay for.
→ Systems: Making Your Online Business Easier to Manage
Discover how practical systems and automation can help you manage an online business without adding unnecessary complexity.
→ Scale: Growing Revenue From an Established Business
Explore ways to increase revenue, improve existing offers and grow a business without making everything more complicated.
Discover More Audio Interviews
Neil Stafford's conversation is part of our growing collection of interviews featuring experienced online marketers and information-business owners.
Each interview offers a different perspective on building, marketing or developing an online business, with the original audio and a downloadable transcript available for visitors.

